Refine
Year of publication
Document Type
- Conference Proceeding (10)
- Part of a Book (6)
- Article (4)
- Book (1)
- Doctoral Thesis (1)
- Working Paper (1)
Has Fulltext
- yes (23)
Keywords
- Urheberrecht (23) (remove)
Publicationstate
- Veröffentlichungsversion (15)
- Zweitveröffentlichung (5)
- Postprint (3)
Reviewstate
- Peer-Review (11)
- (Verlags)-Lektorat (8)
Publisher
- Leibniz-Institut für Deutsche Sprache (3)
- European Language Resources Association (ELRA) (2)
- Linköping University Electronic Press (2)
- Universität zu Köln (2)
- Association Française pour la diffusion du RIDA (1)
- CLARIN (1)
- CLARIN Legal and Ethical Issues Committee (CLIC) (1)
- De Gruyter (1)
- Johns Hopkins University Pres (1)
- Narr (1)
Open Science and language data: Expectations vs. reality. The role of research data infrastructures
(2023)
Language data are essential for any scientific endeavor. However, unlike numerical data, language data are often protected by copyright, as they easily meet the threshold of originality. The role of research infrastructures (such CLARIN, DARIAH, and Text+) is to bridge the gap between uses allowed by statutory exceptions and the requirements of Open Science. This is achieved on the one hand by sharing language data produced by research organisations with the widest possible circle of persons, and on the other by mutualizing efforts towards copyright clearance and appropriate licensing of datasets.
The normative layer of CLARIN is, alongside the organizational and technical layers, an essential part of the infrastructure. It consists of the regulatory framework (statutory law, case law, authoritative guidelines, etc.), the contractual framework (licenses, terms of service, etc.), and ethical norms. Navigating the normative layer requires expertise, experience, and qualified effort. In order to advise the Board of Directors, a standing committee dedicated to legal and ethical issues, the CLIC, was created. Since its establishment in 2012, the CLIC has made considerable efforts to provide not only the BoD but also the general public with information and guidance. It has published many articles (both in proceedings of CLARIN conferences and in its own White Paper Series) and developed several LegalTech tools. It also runs a Legal Information Platform, where accessible information on various issues affecting language resources can be found.
Korpora sind – als idealerweise digital verfüg- und auswertbare Sammlungen von Texten – eine wertvolle empirische Grundlage linguistischer Studien. Eigene Korpora aufzubauen ist, je nach Sprachausschnitt, mit unterschiedlichen Herausforderungen verbunden. Zu allen Texten sollten Metadaten zu den Textentstehungsbedingungen (Zeit, Quelle usw.) erhoben werden, um diese als Variablen in Auswertungen einbeziehen zu können. Andere Informationen wie etwa die Themenzugehörigkeit (oder Annotationen auch unterhalb der Textebene) sind auch hilfreich, in vielerlei Hinsicht aber schwieriger pauschal taxonomisch vorzugeben, geschweige denn, operationell zu ermitteln. Jenseits der »materiellen« Verfügbarkeit der Texte und der technischen Aufbereitung sind es das Urheberrecht, vor allem Lizenz- bzw. Nutzungsrechte, sowie ethische Verantwortung und Persönlichkeitsrechte, die beachtet werden müssen, auch um zu gewährleisten, dass die Daten für die Reproduktion der Studien Dritten rechtssicher zugänglich gemacht werden dürfen. Bevor für ein Vorhaben ein neues Korpus aufgebaut wird, sollte deshalb am besten geprüft werden, ob nicht ein geeignetes bereits zur Verfügung steht. Wenn ein Korpus aufgebaut wird, sollte für eine nachhaltige Aufbewahrung und Zugänglichmachung gesorgt und die Existenz an geeigneter Stelle dokumentiert werden.
Was darf die sprachwissenschaftliche Forschung? Juristische Fragen bei der Arbeit mit Sprachdaten
(2022)
Sich in der Linguistik mit rechtlichen Themen beschäftigen zu müssen, ist auf den ersten Blick überraschend. Da jedoch in den Sprachwissenschaften empirisch gearbeitet wird und Sprachdaten, insbesondere Texte und Ton- und Videoaufnahmen sowie Transkripte gesprochener Sprache, in den letzten Jahren auch verstärkt Sprachdaten internetbasierter Kommunikation, als Basis für die linguistische Forschung dienen, müssen rechtliche Rahmenbedingungen für jede Art von Datennutzung beachtet werden. Natürlich arbeiten auch andere Wissenschaften, wie z. B. die Astronomie oder die Meteorologie, empirisch. Jedoch gibt es einen grundsätzlichen Unterschied der empirischen Basis: Im Gegensatz zu Temperaturen, die gemessen, oder Konstellationen von Himmelskörpern, die beobachtet werden, basieren Sprachdaten auf schriftlichen, mündlichen oder gebärdeten Äußerungen von Menschen, wodurch sich juristisch begründete Beschränkungen ihrer Nutzung ergeben.
N-grams are of utmost importance for modern linguistics and language technology. The legal status of n-grams, however, raises many practical questions. Traditionally, text snippets are considered copyrightable if they meet the originality criterion, but no clear indicators as to the minimum length of original snippets exist; moreover, the solutions adopted in some EU Member States (the paper cites German and French law as examples) are considerably different. Furthermore, recent developments in EU law (the CJEU's Pelham decision and the new right of press publishers) also provide interesting arguments in this debate. The paper presents the existing approaches to the legal protection of n-grams and tries to formulate some clear guidelines as to the length of n-grams that can be freely used and shared.
This paper reports on the efforts of twelve national teams in building the International Comparable Corpus (ICC; https://korpus.cz/icc) that will contain highly comparable datasets of spoken, written and electronic registers. The languages currently covered are Czech, Finnish, French, German, Irish, Italian, Norwegian, Polish, Slovak, Swedish and, more recently, Chinese, as well as English, which is considered to be the pivot language. The goal of the project is to provide much-needed data for contrastive corpus-based linguistics. The ICC corpus is committed to the idea of re-using existing multilingual resources as much as possible and the design is modelled, with various adjustments, on the International Corpus of English (ICE). As such, ICC will contain approximately the same balance of forty percent of written language and 60 percent of spoken language distributed across 27 different text types and contexts. A number of issues encountered by the project teams are discussed, ranging from copyright and data sustainability to technical advances in data distribution.
Making research data publicly available for evaluation or reuse is a fundamental part of good scientific practice. However, regulations such as copyright law can prevent this practice and thereby hamper scientific progress. In Germany, text-based research disciplines have for a long time been mostly unable to publish corpora made from material outside of the public domain, effectively excluding contemporary works. While there are approaches to obfuscate text material in a way that it is no longer covered by the original copyright, many use cases still require the raw textual context for evaluation or follow-up research. Recent changes in copyright now permit text and data mining on copyrighted works. However, questions regarding reusability and sharing of such corpora at a later time are still not answered to a satisfying degree. We propose a workflow that allows interested third parties to access customized excerpts of protected corpora in accordance with current German copyright law and the soon to be implemented guidelines of the Digital Single Market directive. Our prototype is a very lightweight web interface that builds on commonly used repository software and web standards.
Ungoliant: An optimized pipeline for the generation of a very large-scale multilingual web corpus
(2021)
Since the introduction of large language models in Natural Language Processing, large raw corpora have played a crucial role in Computational Linguistics. However, most of these large raw corpora are either available only for English or not available to the general public due to copyright issues. Nevertheless, there are some examples of freely available multilingual corpora for training Deep Learning NLP models, such as the OSCAR and Paracrawl corpora. However, they have quality issues, especially for low-resource languages. Moreover, recreating or updating these corpora is very complex. In this work, we try to reproduce and improve the goclassy pipeline used to create the OSCAR corpus. We propose a new pipeline that is faster, modular, parameterizable, and well documented. We use it to create a corpus similar to OSCAR but larger and based on recent data. Also, unlike OSCAR, the metadata information is at the document level. We release our pipeline under an open source license and publish the corpus under a research-only license.
Contents:
1. Julien Abadji, Pedro Javier Ortiz Suárez, Laurent Romary and Benoît Sagot: "Ungoliant: An Optimized Pipeline for the Generation of a Very Large-Scale Multilingual Web Corpus", S.1-9.
2. Markus Gärtner, Felicitas Kleinkopf, Melanie Andresen and Sibylle Hermann: "Corpus Reusability and Copyright - Challenges and Opportunities", S.10-19.
3. Nils Diewald, Eliza Margaretha and Marc Kupietz: "Lessons learned in Quality Management for Online Research Software Tools in Linguistics", S.20-26.