Volltext-Downloads (blau) und Frontdoor-Views (grau)

Invoking rules in everyday family interactions: a method for appealing to practical reason

  • In this article we examine moments in which parents or other caregivers overtly invoke rules during episodes in which they take issue with, intervene against, and try to change a child’s ongoing behavior or action(s). Drawing on interactional data from four different languages (English, Finnish, German, Polish) and using Conversation Analytic methods, we first illustrate the variety of ways in which parents may use such overt rule invocations as part of their behavior modification attempts, showing them to be functionally versatile interactional objects. Their interactional flexibility notwithstanding, we find that parents typically invoke rules when, in the course of the intervention episode, they encounter trouble with achieving an acceptable compliant outcome. To get at the distinct import of rule formulations in this context, we then compare them to two sequential alternatives: parental expressions of an experienced negative affective state, and parental threats. While the former emphasize aspects of social solidarity, the latter seek to enforce compliance by foregrounding a power asymmetry between the parent and the child. Rule formulations, by contrast, are designedly impersonal and appear to be directed at what the parents construe as shortcomings in common-sense practical reasoning on the child’s part. Reflexively, the child is thereby cast as not having properly applied common-sense ‘practical reason’ when engaging in what is treated as the problematic behavior or action. Overt rule invocations can, therefore, be understood as indexical appeals to practical reason.

Download full text files

Export metadata

Additional Services

Share in Twitter Search Google Scholar

Statistics

frontdoor_oas
Metadaten
Author:Uwe-Alexander KüttnerORCiDGND, Anna VatanenORCiD, Jörg ZinkenGND
URN:urn:nbn:de:bsz:mh39-114546
DOI:https://doi.org/10.1007/s10746-022-09648-0
ISSN:1572-851X
Parent Title (English):Human Studies
Publisher:Springer Nature
Document Type:Article
Language:English
Year of first Publication:2022
Date of Publication (online):2023/01/13
Publishing Institution:Leibniz-Institut für Deutsche Sprache (IDS)
Publicationstate:Veröffentlichungsversion
Reviewstate:Peer-Review
Tag:conversation analysis; family interaction; parental interventions; practical reasoning; rule formulations; rules
GND Keyword:Deutsch; Englisch; Familie; Finnisch; Handlung; Interaktion; Konversationsanalyse; Polnisch; Praktische Vernunft; Regel; Solidarität; Verhaltensmodifikation
Volume:45
Issue:4
First Page:793
Last Page:823
Note:
Finanziert über das DEAL-Konsortium mit Springer Nature
DDC classes:400 Sprache / 400 Sprache, Linguistik
Open Access?:ja
Leibniz-Classification:Sprache, Linguistik
Linguistics-Classification:Pragmalinguistik / Kommunikationsforschung
Program areas:P1: Interaktion
Licence (English):License LogoCreative Commons - Attribution 4.0 International